Aaron Judge free company: Ranking all 30 MLB teams as potential landing spots for the Yankees superstar

Aaron Judge launched his 61st residence run of the yr on Wednesday towards the Toronto Blue Jays, which means he is now tied Roger Maris’ single-season data for each the New York Yankees franchise and the American League as a complete. Seeing as how Judge can also be threatening to win the AL Triple Crown, it is solely truthful to jot down that he is having one in all the greatest offensive seasons in latest historical past. He’ll possible be rewarded for it in the type of the AL’s Most Valuable Player Award as soon as all the ballots are counted this fall.

Judge can be rewarded in one other respect this winter, as he is in line to develop into the offseason’s most sought-after free agent. You might have heard that he turned down the Yankees’ final extension supply in the spring, a deal that will have paid him greater than $210 million. The resolution to wager on himself appears to be like sensible now, and it makes for an attractive query: with whom would possibly he find yourself signing earlier than subsequent season?

We right here at CBS Sports are nothing if not the messy sort, so under we have tiered and ranked all 30 teams primarily based on their perceived probability of signing Judge. We ought to notice that that is extra of an artwork than a science — there’s nonetheless time left in the common season, for Pete’s sake — and that train is for leisure functions solely. In different phrases, do not get too excessive or low in response to your crew’s placement.

With the superb print out of the means, let’s get to rating issues.

Tier 1: No means, no how

30. Pittsburgh Pirates

29. Oakland Athletics

28. Miami Marlins

27. Kansas City Royals

26. Tampa Bay Rays

25. Cincinnati Reds

Again, Judge turned down an extension that will have paid him greater than $210 million. He’s sure to obtain much more this winter. Can you think about the Royals or the Athletics handing out such a contract? Of course you’ll be able to’t; not on this model of the simulation. We would, nonetheless, pay a small price to look at a livestream the place Pirates basic supervisor Ben Cherington presents the concept to proprietor Bob Nutting.

Tier 2: Swing and a miss

24. Detroit Tigers

23. Washington Nationals

22. Baltimore Orioles

21. Milwaukee Brewers

20. Colorado Rockies

19. Los Angeles Angels

None of those teams appear prone to both 1) spend the obligatory cash or 2) make the postseason. Seeing as how the Judge can have his alternative of teams that may and can do each, there is no sense losing a lot time weighing this group’s respective deserves. We will concede that the concept of ​​Judge becoming a member of forces with Mike Trout and Shohei Ohtani is tempting, however the Angels appear extra prone to commerce Ohtani earlier than or after a sale.

Tier 3: Missing a component

18. Arizona Diamondbacks

17. Chicago White Sox

16. Minnesota Twins

15. Cleveland Guardians

The White Sox, Twins, and Guardians will presumably battle once more for the American League Central crown subsequent season. None of them appear prone to splurge on a participant of Judge’s caliber — though the Twins did signal Carlos Correa final offseason, so perhaps something is feasible. The Diamondbacks are a crew on the rise, however they’ve an outfield full of kids, suggesting they need to spend their cash elsewhere.

Tier 4: On the warning observe

14. Philadelphia Phillies

13. San Diego Padres

12. Seattle Mariners

11. Toronto Blue Jays

10. Houston Astros

9. Atlanta Braves

8. Texas Rangers

7. Louis Cardinals

6. Chicago Cubs

If you instructed us one in all these teams obtained concerned on Judge, we would not be shocked; we’re simply not relying on them making a critical run due to this or that issue. The Padres and Rangers have made a number of notable additions to their rosters over the previous yr. We’re unsure if both has room for the form of deal that the Judge will demand. The Mariners, Blue Jays, Astros, and Braves all appear extra prone to concentrate on retaining or extending their very own — the Braves, for occasion, should kind out whether or not or not they will be retaining Dansby Swanson on the town. The Cardinals have been in the working for Juan Soto, suggesting they could have the urge for food for one other big-time slugger. Would they pony up for Judge? We’re skeptical. Then there’s the Cubs, who will in all probability focus their power (and their cash) in direction of upgrading at shortstop.


5. Boston Red Sox

We’re skeptical of rating the Red Sox this extremely as properly. Chaim Bloom has proven little willingness to spend, and it could appear odd to commerce Mookie Betts solely to show round a number of winters later and signal Judge. Besides, they’ve to determine what they’re doing with the left facet of their infield, in shortstop Xander Bogaerts and third baseman Rafael Devers. There are solely so many teams who can realistically meet Judge’s value level, although, and the Red Sox occur to be a kind of teams.

Tier 5: The favourites

At final we have accomplished it, we have reached the last 4, or the teams who we expect have the greatest possibilities of signing Judge this winter. Let’s dive proper in.

4. San Francisco Giants

One front-office supply scoffed at us itemizing the Giants as a good landing spot for Judge, however hear us out on this one. The Giants have made previous performs for (*30*) Stanton and Bryce Harper, suggesting they’ve the urge for food for a middle-of-the-order thumper. Much of San Francisco’s current core is growing older into retirement or decline, leaving Farhan Zaidi able the place it is previous time to import a brand new face of the franchise. The Giants will shed a number of long-term commitments each this winter and subsequent, too, giving them the monetary freedom to make a splash. And hey, it might not assist that Judge performed in faculty about three hours from Oracle Park, however it in all probability will not damage. Maybe that supply will show to be appropriate; we simply suppose the Giants are on account of emerge as a critical darkish horse for a high free agent once more someday quickly.

3. New York Mets

2. Los Angeles Dodgers

We aren’t fairly sure by regulation to incorporate the Dodgers and Mets close to the high of this record (and others which might be related in idea), however we’re nearer to that than not. The Dodgers have a number of large contracts coming off the books this offseason, together with these belonging to Trea Turner and David Price. They may free up much more cash by non-tendering Cody Bellinger, ought to they select to take action. As a results of their obvious monetary flexibility, they get the larger rating. The Mets, for their half, have proven no actual aversion to spending as a lot cash as they want beneath Steve Cohen. Even so, Billy Eppler can have some main inside enterprise to deal with this offseason, as ace Jacob deGrom and nearer Edwin Diaz can each hit the open market. Would the Mets actually be keen to retain these two and signal Judge? Maybe so.

1. New York Yankees

And but, we’ve got to go along with the Yankees as Judge’s high potential suitor. Yes, that is the coward’s alternative, and sure, they’ve heretofore did not lock down Judge. There are a number of elements at play that would coerce a better sense of urgency from them when the two sides discuss once more this winter. For one, Brian Cashman has to know his crew can be far worse off with out Judge in tow. For one other, the Yankees hardly ever let their homegrown stars go away in free company (Robinson Canó is the exception), and it could be a tough promote to let Judge stroll after he topples Maris’ file. Then there’s the Mets issue: are you able to think about the temper round the Yankees if they permit Judge to high-tail it throughout the metropolis? Maybe Cashman and the Yankees have the abdomen to face up to it all, however we’re sticking with the incumbent till there’s purpose to depend them out.

Leave a Comment