Here you have it, lists of Utah, BYU, Utah State football players who are being ‘honored’ for what they haven’t done yet

College football watch lists.

What are they good for?

Absolutely nothing… except all of the greed-filled convention juggling, the cash seize by faculty directors, the arguing between coaches, the transfers, the huge NIL offers, the doldrums of a buzzard-hot summer season have pushed you to lunacy’s edge and getting pumped within the pre-preseason by means of hype is what soothes your football-craving soul.

Then it’d imply a bit one thing.


But each July, as certain as fireworks are set off by careless of us who pay no consideration to the truth that Utah neighborhoods and huge expanses of land are parched and able to ignite, faculties — on this case, BYU, Utah and Utah State — ship out notifications about their players who have been named to this watch listing or that, this preseason All-America crew or that.

Such watch lists have misplaced their which means, if they ever had any, on a couple of accounts.

First, there are so many players on so many lists for so many awards that it is gotten to the bloated level the place it could be simpler — or no less than extra notable, extra selective — to call players who have been left off the lists.

The unwatched lists.

For instance, these are some of the watch-list awards for which sure native players might be, might be, or have been nominated: the Maxwell Award, the Doak Walker Award, the Bednarik Award, the Lou Groza Award, the Ray Guy Award , the Biletnikoff Award, the Bronko Nagurski Trophy, the Butkus Award, the Outland Trophy, the Davey O’Bien Award. And a slew of preseason All-America groups.

Did we depart anybody out? Yup. Embarrassment

There are awards for virtually each place on the sector, for coaches, too, and the quantity of preseason nominees for every varies from lots to a complete lot. The Nagurski Trophy, for occasion, has 85 players on its watch listing. The Butkus Award has 51 from 43 faculties.

Everybody’s within the pool.

Utah players on watch lists, a couple of of them on a number of lists, with some yet to be introduced, embrace: Cam Rising, Clark Phillips III, Junior Tafuna, Braeden Daniels, Mohamoud Diabate, Cole Bishop, Dalton Kincaid, Brant Kuithe, and Tavion Thomas There are extra on preseason all-conference lists.

BYU players: Jaren Hall, Payton Wilgar, Ben Bywater, Clark Barrington, Blake Freeland, Connor Pay, Isaac Rex, Puka Nacua, Ryan Rehkow, Jake Oldroyd, Tyler Batty.

Utah State: Calvin Tyler Jr., Logan Bonner, Andre Grayson, Stephen Kotsanlee.

Second, what variety of season-specific “honor” is it to be named to a 2022 listing singing praises for athletes who haven’t even suited up yet?

It’s ridiculous, when you give it some thought, honoring players for the approaching season for both what they’ve done previously or what they’ve proven potential to do within the unplayed video games forward.

The query might be moderately requested: Before the season begins, should not each participant on each crew be watched? You by no means know who may emerge in a contemporary slate of video games.

And that is the purpose right here, actually. It’s to not demean any of the nominees. If they’re on any of these lists, they’ve achieved private success of their previous. You can see the names and, generally, have seen their video games.

They’re good. Are they higher than their unnamed teammates? Probably, perhaps.

I talked to a participant a couple of seasons again who was not named to any such watch listing, and, like best athletes, he at first acted prefer it was no massive deal, however then he whispered that he was, in his opinion, each bit as priceless to his crew, each bit as proficient and laborious working in his personal realm as his teammates who had been named. He admitted he was a mixture of miffed and ticked off concerning the deal.

Third, in a crew sport like school football, there’s a lot consideration paid to particular person players, a relentless push to single them out with accolades and awards. Everybody’s trying for a star. I get it. That’s the best way it’s. That’s what attracts eyeballs. But typically it is an excessive amount of.

And I write that — full disclosure right here — as a Heisman Trophy voter. Been doing that for years. But each time I sit all the way down to fill out that poll, naming so as my high three players, the thought ricochets off the corners of my thoughts: Is this man, are these guys, actually one of the best CFB players in all of the land? Really? At least I’ve had an opportunity to observe a season’s value of video games by then.

The preseason stuff is worse.

Ultimately, these lists are meaningless, and everybody’s absolutely conscious.

Honoring players for a coming season for what they may do, or for what they’ve done in different seasons, is about as foolish as an awards-crazed surroundings will get. Even if stated players go on to nice success within the months forward, for the time being it’s empty, it is mindless, it is hype.

Even if it makes you really feel higher about your crew, about your crew’s prospects, about your self, in a interval of avarice in school football, a time when the emphasis on the game facilities on cash, on faculty and convention positioning, on enterprise, go go forward and use it for what it is value.

Not lots.

Leave a Comment