Opinion | Not tackling in practices is one way to make football safer


Researchers have lengthy warned in regards to the risks of deal with football, as I wrote final month. The sport typically outcomes in severe head accidents, the cumulative impact of which leads to a degenerative neurological illness referred to as power traumatic encephalopathy.

But there is a answer that may considerably cut back the lifetime danger of CTE: eliminating stay tackling in observe. Dartmouth College took that unprecedented step in 2010, demonstrating that the game will be performed extra safely.

I just lately spoke with the college’s head coach Eugene F. “Buddy” Teevens III to perceive what he calls “the Dartmouth way.” A condensed and calmly edited model of our dialog is beneath:

Leana Wen: Your work to minimize out stay tackling throughout observe is fairly a paradigm shift. What led you to make this transfer?

Buddy Teevens: The extra contact you might have, the extra instances you are hit, the extra you get damage. We all observe way greater than we play, and coaches management the observe discipline. If we restrict contact throughout observe, that in itself will restrict accidents.

People typically misconstrue what we do. We deal with day-after-day in observe, however we deal with inanimate objects, not folks. I inform gamers and prospects that they’ll by no means make a deal with on a Dartmouth participant or be tackled by a Dartmouth participant throughout their 4 years.

As a outcome, we have now fewer accidents, and fewer concussions or subconcussive hits to the top than in all probability another Division I staff, and, I’d enterprise to guess, in all probability most groups in the nation.

Wen: How do you educate tackling in order that gamers are ready to deal with throughout video games, if they do not observe tackling one one other?

Teevens: You can educate the bodily contact points with out bodily contacting an individual. Players can deal with a dummy at full pace with out jeopardizing themselves. We use completely different types of dummies together with a robotic shifting dummy referred to as the “cellular digital participant,” which was developed right here at Dartmouth with the college of engineering.

We do extra tackling drills and break down every section of the deal with. For instance, to educate response after the contact, slightly than having two guys run into one another and bang their heads, we put them collectively after which have them react. We observe smarter and improve method.

We went from lacking a superb bunch of tackles, like 15 to 20 a recreation, to simply three to 5. In my opinion, that is as a result of we deal with greater than anyone else — we simply do not deal with one another.

Wen: When you instituted these adjustments, did you face loads of resistance from the previous guard who mentioned, this is simply not how we play football?

Teevens: Definitely. They say it is a toughness factor and also you suck it up. Injury is a part of the sport.

I’m making an attempt to persuade folks that there is one other way to do it and it is going to be safer in the long run. You find yourself with fewer gamers out with accidents, particularly head accidents. A damaged hand will heal. A broken mind could not.

Wen: Your management was instrumental in getting the Ivy League to make the large change in 2016 to eradicate all full-contact hitting throughout common season practices. But the Ivy League nonetheless permits tackling throughout offseason practices, and not one of the different school leagues have made related reforms. Why not, and why have so few different faculties adopted your lead?

Teevens: It’s actually dangerous for the teaching employees to make a change like this, regardless that they know it is in the perfect curiosity of their gamers’ well being. They don’t need to danger dropping on recreation day.

When I first made the change at Dartmouth, folks mentioned, “Yeah proper, you are an fool, you are gonna get fired.” The first season, I used to be apprehensive. I assumed, man, I hope this works!

We’ve had a substantial amount of success. We’ve received three Ivy League championships and have been ranked nationally, offensively and defensively, for a number of years.

Real change is going to take convention places of work saying that we’re going to do that collectively, everybody’s on the identical web page, and we’re all going to eradicate stay tackling in observe. Otherwise, the one-off danger is too excessive for lots of groups. Because what everybody needs is wins, and wins will not be measured by what number of concussions they’ve prevented.

Wen: Have you had difficulties with recruiting gamers or is the Dartmouth Way a recruiting benefit?

Teevens: Kids assume they are going to stay endlessly, however mothers and dads search us out. I discuss to my gamers about the way it’s nice to have an athletic dream, however they’ve an instructional dream, too. Very few of them will make it to the NFL. I say to them that once they’re performed with football right here, I would like them to be medical doctors, legal professionals, engineers and enterprise leaders.

What we’re doing is so simplistic and customary sense; it is simply opposite to what folks have performed for many years. But except we alter the way we coach the sport, we’re not going to have a recreation to coach.

Leave a Comment