Rosenthal: An open letter to Tony La Russa

Tony, first off, I hope you feel properly. You have not managed since Aug. 28, lacking time since you required a process to restore the circuitry of your pacemaker. You’re watching video games from a collection at Guaranteed Rate Field and White Sox normal supervisor Rick Hahn informed reporters Tuesday the staff will comply with the recommendation of medical consultants as to if and when you’ll handle once more. Returning would imply resuming a anxious job on the most anxious time of the season with a coronary heart downside as you flip 78 on Oct. 4. But even when medical doctors cleared you to work once more, that is not merely a medical query. Not in case you are considering of the very best pursuits of the staff.

I do know you are watching the video games. I do know you are conscious of the White Sox, 63-65 while you left the membership, even 10-4 since bench coach Miguel Cairo, 48, took over as appearing supervisor. You can rationalize this turnaround following a five-game shedding streak, dismiss it as coincidence. Knowing you because the late Nineteen Eighties, I think about that is precisely the way you see it. You’re Tony La Russa, three-time World Series champion, Hall of Fame supervisor. You did not attain these heights considering another person might do a greater job.

But Tony, it is extra apparent day by day: Cairo is doing a greater job. Yes, the staff is lastly getting more healthy, the offense is lastly hitting with energy, the gamers are lastly responding to the urgency of their state of affairs, three video games out within the weak AL Central with 20 to play. Maybe all that might have occurred for those who have been nonetheless the supervisor. But Cairo is bringing vitality. Communicating with gamers. Holding them accountable. All issues possibly you thought you have been doing. But evidently, we weren’t doing properly sufficient.


Miguel Cairo (Kamil Krzaczynski / USA Today Sports)

Under Cairo, not are there sometimes weird in-game choices that spark outcry. No longer does the membership function as a fiefdom the place the supervisor’s phrase guidelines above all. And most significantly, not are the gamers underachieving the way in which they did for 5 months.

Meanwhile, the query looms over the membership: Are you coming again? You would possibly say, “That’s up to the medical doctors.” But actually, it is up to you. Your fame has taken successful throughout your second tenure with the White Sox, despite the fact that the staff gained the division final season, your first as a supervisor since 2011. By stepping down, you might exit gracefully, present dignity and do proper by proprietor Jerry Reinsdorf, who introduced you out of retirement as a manner of atonement for firing you in 1986.

There, Tony. I’ll say it. You ought to announce that you’ll not handle the White Sox. That you solely need what’s finest for the staff. And that what’s finest for the staff is Cairo persevering with within the place for the remainder of the season, along with your full help.

Such a gesture, I do know, isn’t in your nature. You are a fighter, all the time have been. And for those who and Reinsdorf had been extra self-aware, he wouldn’t have requested you to come out of retirement within the first place, and you wouldn’t have accepted. Reinsdorf’s loyalty is maybe his most interesting high quality. But his stubbornness in hiring you jeopardized the staff’s aggressive window. Beneficial because it might need been for you, Tony — and the way in which White Sox followers get on you, I’m undecided it was all that helpful — the transfer was a disservice to the staff’s entrance workplace, its coaches, gamers and followers.

Almost no supervisor is considered extremely by all 26 of his gamers. Pitchers see issues otherwise than hitters. Veterans see issues otherwise than kids. But Tony, I feel you’d agree it is a totally different technology of gamers now. Some is perhaps intimidated by you. Some would possibly choose a looser atmosphere. Some would possibly require extra vitality from their supervisor. Obviously, you possibly can by no means please all of them. And gamers must be accountable for their very own performances, particularly while you virtually all the time attempt to shield them publicly.

Still, what did Cairo do after his first loss on his first night time on the job, as first reported by USA Today? Call a gathering and name out gamers for his or her lack of effort. New expectations have been set. The message, in accordance to one participant, was easy: Give me what you bought.

Maybe you conveyed the identical ideas, Tony. But possibly some gamers wanted to hear the message from a brand new voice. Not all — sure veterans, particularly, operate simply high quality irrespective of who the supervisor is. But Cairo is just 10 years faraway from his enjoying days. He walks up and down the dugout, speaking to gamers, encouraging them. And though you converse fluent Spanish, no less than one White Sox individual believes that Cairo, a local Venezuelan, connects extra naturally with the staff’s sizable contingent of Latin gamers.

Other White Sox folks suppose the staff’s rash of soft-tissue accidents maybe stemmed, partly, from the gamers’ lax method — not all the time working arduous, then asking an excessive amount of from their muscle groups briefly bursts. Such evaluation is solely anecdotal. But the inference was clear: A staff takes on the character of its supervisor, and also you didn’t maintain the gamers to a excessive sufficient commonplace.

Your relationship with coaches was one other subject. Most employees right now are extremely collaborative. Your type is much extra autonomous. Some coaches have been OK with that, I’m informed. Others weren’t. Your emphasis on hits and speak to ran counter to the hitting coaches’ targets for reaching energy by means of persistence. Cairo cited his respect for you in explaining why he kept away from calling out the staff sooner; clearly, he didn’t really feel empowered to take a stand.

None of that is new. Tony, when you all the time had coaches you trusted — Dave Duncan, Dave McKay, amongst others — you have been additionally all the time one thing of a one-man present, and never with out motive. You have been Tony La Russa, and if some folks sneered at you for appearing like the neatest man within the room, properly, you usually have been. Your supporters say you possibly can nonetheless run a recreation in addition to any supervisor, however enter out of your coaches is nonetheless important. Today’s recreation is a lot extra advanced than it was within the early Nineteen Nineties, and even the early 2010s. Not that ordering intentional walks on 1-2 counts was a suitable technique in any manner, a lot as you would possibly argue it was.

Cairo, no less than up to now, appears to haven’t any such issues motivating gamers or together with his coaches in his decision-making. His transfer of Elvis Andrus to the leadoff spot proved a grasp stroke, serving to spark the offense. It’s unimaginable to say whether or not the White Sox are enjoying extra freely as a result of they’re successful, or whether or not they’re successful as a result of they’re enjoying extra freely. The protection, in accordance to the main metrics, continues to be moderately flawed. And the way in which the Guardians, winners of 5 straight, are enjoying, possibly the Sox’s belated push beneath Cairo will show to be too little, too late.

It would not matter. Tony. You’ve acquired an opportunity to take the excessive highway right here, to again up the team-first ethos you have all the time preached. It’s truly a straightforward manner out, and I’m pretty sure it could be well-received, as a result of it is the suitable factor to do.

For those that knew you at your finest, it is tough seeing you portrayed as a cartoon. Younger followers and gamers would possibly by no means admire all you achieved in Oakland and St. Louis. At least allow them to see you, in your last act, respect the sport, your group, the proprietor who made the controversial determination to rent you, the coach who succeeded you as supervisor.

There could be no disgrace in acknowledging that it did not work out the way in which you envisioned. Take the noble path. Show this isn’t all about you. Make the announcement that simply would possibly save the White Sox season: It’s Miggy’s staff now.

(Top picture: Denny Medley / USA Today Sports)

Leave a Comment