SF Giants’ odd moves at MLB deadline leave them behind LA

Their playoff hopes fading with each mistake they commit, the Giants had an opportunity to reset themselves at the commerce deadline and begin constructing for subsequent 12 months and past. Even although they’re only some video games out of a Wild Card spot, the Giants aren’t contenders in any sense of the phrase, barring a miraculous turnaround (and enjoying satisfactory protection).

Despite their questionable roster development, there are some vivid spots that may be much more precious to true contenders. Veteran bats like Joc Pederson and Wilmer Flores who might have helped the lineups of present contenders. Any variety of bullpen items with confirmed observe information. Even arguably the most effective beginning pitcher in the marketplace in Carlos Rodon, whose quirky contract choice and sketchy damage historical past could have blunted the return a bit, however nonetheless would have introduced again a precious piece or two. (What does it say about the remainder of the roster that every one these tasty commerce chips have added as much as a 51-54 file and 7 straight losses in opposition to the Dodgers?)

This group by no means breathes the phrase “rebuild,” however no matter you need to name it, there was a possibility at the commerce deadline. They had the prospect so as to add to their stash of prospects, doubtlessly some who had been able to contribute at the Major League degree, and begin retooling for subsequent 12 months whereas penning this season off as a bump within the street.

That would have made sense. Instead, the Giants traded a couple of peripheral items for marginal returns, held on to their most precious belongings, after which gave imprecise, New Age-ish statements about residing for the current.

So once more:

What are they doing?

If the Giants are really dedicated to a playoff push this 12 months, it stands to motive they’d have tried so as to add to the Major League roster slightly than subtract. Fixing the protection would have been an ideal place to start out. Or including one other dependable arm to the bullpen, or one other bat for Gabe Kapler to the platoon, something.

But, no. The Giants arguably weakened their roster by buying and selling away Darin Ruf and Curt Casali, the latter of which made the least quantity of sense in the event that they had been really nonetheless making an attempt to contend, contemplating the struggles of Joey Bart this 12 months. The solely participant added to the staff was JD Davis, who does not precisely transfer the needle. Given the apparent choices of bettering proper now, or getting a lot worse proper now to enhance later, they selected getting barely worse now and barely worse later.

None of this is smart. This was the proper time for a delicate rebuild with a watch in the direction of reloading the roster in free company this winter. Was the marketplace for Rodon so weak that the Giants could not even get one high-level prospect for him? Hard to imagine, even with Rodon’s standing as a rental. He’s a top-of-the-rotation arm that may swing a playoff collection, and the Giants could not discover a single taker?

How about Pederson? Or Flores? Or even Brandon Belt? Hanging on to them is comprehensible should you take the Giants’ statements about contending for the Wild Card at face worth, however that is laborious to do. This staff merely is not adequate the way in which they’re enjoying now.

The Giants ought to have tried to collect as many prospects as they may, even when the returns had been lower than what they’d hoped, and crossed their fingers that one in all two of them could be able to contribute subsequent 12 months. This season hasn’t gone how they anticipated, which occurs. But the most effective groups begin to regroup sooner slightly than later, with a watch on the long run.

But as a substitute, the Giants stood pat and embraced the malaise. They aren’t near both the Dodgers or Padres, who each appear to be working in a unique universe. They’re caught in quicksand, unable to decide to a full rebuild and holding out hope they’re truly a playoff staff and their eyes have been mendacity to them for the previous few months.

The worst factor the Giants might have carried out at the commerce deadline was nothing. And sadly, that is precisely what they did.

Dave Tobener (@gggiants on Twitter) is a lifelong Giants fan whose household has had season tickets for over 30 years. He’s been fortunate sufficient to by no means miss a World Series recreation within the City in his lifetime, nonetheless is not fully over 2002 and lives and dies with the Giants yearly.

Leave a Comment