The case for Carlos Beltran as a Baseball Hall of Famer

Here is a query I imagine each Hall of Fame voter ought to be asking about Carlos Beltran:

Did you suppose he was a Hall of Famer going into the 2017 season?

Because whereas Beltran devastated his repute by what he did that 12 months, he didn’t enhance his Cooperstown case. In his age-40 marketing campaign, Beltran hit simply .231 with an OPS 19 % under league common, factoring in ballpark and league.

Before that season started, Beltran had 421 homers and 312 steals (he had zero in 2017), and his 86.4 % success fee on steals stays the very best for the 366 gamers who’ve amassed at the least 200 thefts. He had an essential double off Boston’s Craig Kimbrel in Division Series Game 4 — on the street — in 2017, however in any other case had a principally unfavorable affect for the Astros in a playoff by which he was 3-for-20 (.150) with one RBI.

So it was effectively earlier than the season of unlawful signal stealing by which Beltran established himself among the many greatest postseason performers in historical past. Even together with 2017, he completed with a 1.021 OPS (sixth-best for the 283 gamers with at the least 125 postseason plate appearances). Beltran had 16 homers in 65 playoff video games and was 11-for-11 in steals, strolling (37) extra usually than he struck out (33).

And he handed the attention take a look at. Beltran was a dynamic participant. A switch-hitter who excelled on each side of the ball and on the bases. I’ve lengthy felt that a very good class of middle fielders have been damage in Hall voting by enjoying within the shadow of a no-doubt candidate in Ken Griffey Jr. If I have been rating the very best of that group after Griffey, I might go: 1. Beltran. 2. Jim Edmonds. 3. Andrew Jones. 4. Bernie Williams. 5. Kenny Lofton. 6. Johnny Damon. 7. Torii Hunter. 8. Steve Finley. 9. Ellis Burks. 10. Mike Cameron.


Carlos Beltran throughout his enjoying tenure with the Mets
Getty Images

Carlos Beltran in the outfield during his tenure with the Royals
Carlos Beltran within the outfield throughout his tenure with the Royals
Getty Images

Beltran is on the Hall of Fame poll for the primary time, and when the announcement comes Tuesday he’ll nearly actually fall brief of the 75 % of votes essential for election. But I voted for him. Because I believed he was a Hall of Famer going into his now ignoble 2017 season, and nothing that occurred that 12 months helped his statistical candidacy.

I’m reminded of Mike Mussina retiring after the 2008 season with 270 wins. I requested him why not preserve going to attempt to get to 300 and all however assure Hall of Fame inclusion. Mussina responded that he had already assembled his Hall of Fame candidacy. That all of his greatest years have been behind him. That for those who thought he was a Hall of Famer, it was for what he had already executed, not what he may do in piecemeal to chase a milestone.

I really feel that explains my vote for Beltran too. He had constructed — in my opinion — a Hall of Fame résumé earlier than 2017 as a five-tool middle fielder with excessive achievement and as one of the very best postseason performers ever — a massive deal in my course of as a result of the precise concept in baseball is to win , not simply to generate statistics. So excelling in large moments ought to matter vastly. It was what nudged Curt Schilling to no-brainer Hall of Famer territory for me and why I voted for the righty 10 out of 10 instances earlier than he got here off the poll simply as Beltran got here on.


Carlos Beltran runs the bases with the Astros
Carlos Beltran runs the bases with the Astros
Getty Images

For those that withheld a Beltran vote as a punishment, I might say that Beltran has already been punished. He is the lone Astros participant named in MLB’s report on the scandal. Yes, he was an initiator and proponent of the rubbish can-banging scheme, however even at 40, he was nonetheless simply a participant. Alex Cora was the bench coach. AJ Hinch was the supervisor. They wanted to be the adults within the room who stopped this. Instead, Cora was a co-conspirator of this system. Hinch, even whereas saying he disapproved of the signal stealing, didn’t act forcefully sufficient to cease it.

Both have been suspended for a 12 months, each have been again managing a 12 months later. Beltran was fired as Mets supervisor earlier than ever serving even a day in spring coaching.


Carlos Beltran while being introduced as Mets manager
Carlos Beltran whereas being launched as Mets supervisor
Getty Images

For anybody who desires to brandish the morality clause, advantageous. We are wanting on the totality of a baseball life. In 2011, Beltran opened the Carlos Beltran Baseball Academy in his native Puerto Rico to attempt to deal with lecturers and athletics — 27 gamers who attended the academy have reached professional ball up to now, together with two main leaguers. Also, no participant was extra vocal in demanding that gamers who didn’t converse English as a first language have been supplied clubhouse translators so — amongst different causes — they’d not keep away from interactions with teammates or reporters for worry of being misunderstood or saying the improper factor. The implementation of this coverage has been a 100% high quality addition for Major League Baseball.

When I have a look at the poll yearly, I attempt to suppose of every baseball life in full and in steadiness. When I did that for Beltran, I put a checkmark subsequent to his title.

Leave a Comment