Yankees must give up key prospects to land stars at the deadline

If you’re keen on prospects, this isn’t the column for you.

I feel the Yankees ought to commerce what they’ve to so as to land Nationals slugger Juan Soto. Failing that, they need to do the similar to purchase Reds ace Luis Castillo. In the better of all worlds for the group — and their followers — go get them each.

Because it’s onerous to be amongst the 50-100 gamers who actually matter in a serious league season. And in the event you assume you’ve 5 of them percolating in your system, you might be nearly definitely delusional.

The solely time in my 30-plus years of doing this that I noticed one New York crew even have this sort of accumulation at one time was the Yankees of the early Nineteen Nineties. And the magic of then GM Stick Michael was that he knew the most essential group to scout was your individual. He protected, particularly Bernie Williams, however then Derek Jeter, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada and Mariano Rivera, too.

Everyone else was obtainable to pursue championships. I bear in mind in 1995 that the minor league wing of the Yankees group fought like hell not to embrace a pitching prospect named Marty Janzen in a commerce for David Cone. The Yanks do not make the playoffs for the first time in 14 years with out Cone. Janzen had a 6.39 ERA in 27 profession minor league video games.

The following season there was outrage about buying and selling a first-round decide named Matt Drews for Cecil Fielder, who solely helped the Yankees win a World Series. Drews by no means appeared in a serious league sport. In 2003, Brandon Claussen pitched splendidly in his main league debut in the Subway Series, so it was handled as if Whitey Ford was dispatched when a month later he was dealt to the Reds for Aaron Boone, who later in that season would hit a fairly enormous homer you might need seen or heard about.

Juan Soto and Luis Castillo
Juan Soto and Luis Castillo
USA TODAY Sports; Getty Images

Brian Cashman, a Gene Michael disciple, has excelled at scouting his personal. His worst trades are most likely certainly one of his first huge ones (sending Mike Lowell to the Marlins for 3 became nobodies) and certainly one of his most up-to-date huge ones (sending 4 interesting prospects to Texas for became a no one Joey Gallo). That is a wonderful monitor file for two-plus many years.

If something, Cashman’s best regrets aren’t about trades he made, however ones he did not — as examples: for Justin Verlander throughout the 2017 season or Gerrit Cole after that 12 months.

He has a crew this 12 months ok to win a championship. It is founding a bit now. Like each roster, it has defects. And Cashman needs to be utilizing his system aggressively to mend holes and lift title possibilities. Because if historical past is the information, the Yankees most likely haven’t got pretty much as good a prospect base as they imagine. Cashman’s success has been primarily in duping others that it’s higher than it’s.

Consider that via Tuesday, there have been 54 gamers in the majors who signed their first professional contract with the Yankees. That was third to the Astros (61) and Cardinals (57). But Houston and St. Louis have a better quantity of above-average gamers who began on their farms. Among place gamers, the Yankees have Aaron Judge and … The second finest is probably Orioles defensive whiz shortstop Jorge Mateo or Giants second baseman Thairo Estrada (do not forget that Gleyber Torres was initially a Cub). The subsequent finest drafted place participant this 12 months has been Rob Refsnyder (has anyone seen Brett Gardner?). The pitching is healthier with Nestor Cortes, Jordan Montgomery, David Robertson, Luis Severino and Garrett Whitlock. But it’s not overwhelming.


Get all the newest reside and native protection from the New York Post as the Yankees and Mets face off for Game 2 of the 2022 Subway Series.


So is Anthony Volpe going to be as nice as the Yankees imagine? Oswald Peraza? Jason Dominguez? Austin Wells? The phalanx of strong-armed pitchers the Yanks have up and down their system? Maybe they’ve upgraded and like the Astros and Cardinals and now the Dodgers and haven’t solely quantity, however plenty of high quality. But historical past says do not guess on that.

And in the event you make a mistake, you make a mistake. The Dodgers have survived buying and selling Yordan Alvarez for Josh Fields, the Astros buying and selling Josh Hader for Carlos Gomez. Good organizations preserve discovering extra expertise. Volpe was the thirtieth decide in a draft, Judge thirty first.

Anthony Volpe
Anthony Volpe
Getty Images

Consider that 5 years in the past, the Yankees have been seen as having certainly one of the finest programs in the sport. If going into that 12 months they have been requested for his or her finest 5 prospects for, say, Mike Trout, there would have been screams that you may’t commerce 5 gamers who’re in the high 87 in accordance to Baseball America in the complete sport even for Trout . But, after all, you possibly can have traded Torres, Clint Frazier, Blake Rutherford, Mateo and James Kaprielian.

These lists are imperfect. Judge was sixth on that checklist and practically received the AL MVP that 12 months. It is weird to me what number of media members and followers who’ve by no means seen a prospect carry his arm or swing a bat will scream {that a} prospect cannot be traded based mostly on the place he’s on certainly one of these lists. Again, possibly Volpe will likely be nice or possibly he will likely be Jesus Montero.

It is Cashman’s job to separate the Judges from the Rutherfords. But even when it hurts to transfer the years of management, low costs and chance, there is no such thing as a guesswork on Soto. He’s 23 and the hardest out in the sport. Castillo got here into Yankee Stadium a couple of weeks again and was winking at Yankees personnel he knew — having fun with himself throughout an audition in entrance of 41,000 plus in The Bronx whereas taming the residence crew for one run in seven innings.

Soto and Castillo stopped being prospects way back. They are in that small group that basically matter — main league difference-makers. The sort you progress no matter prospects are mandatory to go get.

Leave a Comment